Musical Improvisation Basics - Four Strategies For Playing Wrong Notes


While it probably doesn't seem like this would help - let's face it - if you are unwilling to play a lot of wrong notes, you're never going to learn how to do anything hard. And improvising is hard! It isn't something that you can do safely, with the assurance that you will look good while trying to get good at it. You won't look good. You won't sound good -- and the sooner you realize this, the sooner you will be able to do something of real value.

Strangely, we are from a culture that reinforces the idea that we should always look good. I mean there are actually people who think you should look good when you're sick. When you get up in the middle of the night. Or when you haven't slept for 36 hours.

Get the picture?

So, now that that's said - what is the best strategy for playing wrong notes and actually making progress at the same time?

De-emphasizing Note Values

I have found that the best way to start is by de-emphasizing note values - focussing instead upon rhythm, texture, density and shape. Music is way more than just the notes you play, and note selection tends to be the very thing that stops people in their tracks. Thus, my "Wrong Note Strategy."

The following are possible points of departure for playing wrong notes - properly:

Melodic Shape - Conceptualize a melody - don't get too specific with notes, but think only in terms of the overall shape of the line. Does it go up? Does it climb? Does it jump? If you have a hard time, try creating a melody on your instrument that is shaped like something else. I think it was John Cage (a rather famous composer) that used the New York skyline as the basis for a piece of music. My vote is, if John Cage can do it, we can too.

Density - Think about density. Are there a lot of notes all close together? Or are they spaced wide apart? Density shape is determined by where there is little space between notes, and where there is a lot of space. It is applicable melodically, harmonically and rythmically. I think there are even methods of encoding data that use this approach (can't remember the name of it). I figure, if it's OK for Intel to use this concept for data, I think it's OK for us to use it too.

Rhythm - What about a rhythmic approach? What if note values were totally unimportant, and we thought only percussively about the music? Like using blocks of notes - dissonances as though playing drums with the keyboard (or whatever)? It seems to have worked for legions of 20th Century composers, so why not for us?

Texture - How about making sounds - funny sounds - on our instrument? I remember working with a violinist from the LA Philharmonic, who told me she couldn't improvise. I asked if she could make noises. She said, "Oh sure! I like making really funny noises like this; and this; and this." We proceeded to "play funny sounds" for the next hour and a half, experimenting with all sorts of melody, harmony, rhythm and texture - coming up with some really beautiful stuff, after which she asked, "was that improvising?" I said, it sure was, and she was totally changed by the experience.

I love that story, because it really shows that all we really need is permission to play "wrong" notes. Once we are willing to do that, then we can experiment - often on a very high level - with the vital textural, rhythmic, shape and density aspects of music.

It still communicates, it's genuinely creative, and it really is music.

So play some wrong notes today!

©2000-2005 Ben Dowling, the author of "The Metaphysics of Improvisation" - is a pianist, composer and an authority on music improvisation and publishes Music- Improv.com, a web site that provides useful paradigms and practices for musicians interested in expanding their ability to improvise. Learn more about "The Metaphysics of Improvisation" and "The Music Continuum" by visiting http://www.music-improv.com







Related News



Support Grows For Blanket Music Licensing - Slashdot

Support Grows For Blanket Music Licensing
Slashdot -6 hours ago
Anti-Globalism sends in Ars coverage of a speech by Jim Griffin, who is a consultant for Warner, one of the big four music labels. ...
Support Grows For Blanket Music LicensingSlashdot
all 4 news articles


Atlantic's Jerry Wexler Showed - Wall Street Journal

Washington Post

Atlantic's Jerry Wexler Showed
Wall Street Journal -Aug 18, 2008
The 14 albums Wexler and Franklin made together resulted in music for the ages. As a producer, Wexler made records to capture moments born of preparation ...
Legendary Hitmaker Jerry WexlerNPR
Legendary Music Executive Jerry Wexler Passed Away At His Home In ...AHN
JERRY WEXLER 1917-2008 jerry wexler A music great rememberedUncut.co.uk
Chatter Shmatter - Washington Post
all 852 news articles

Music review: Wilco impressive in one of best concerts of the summer - Salt Lake Tribune

Music review: Wilco impressive in one of best concerts of the summer
Salt Lake Tribune, United States -11 hours ago
By David Burger Jeff Tweedy sings while John Stirratt plays bass as Wilco plays Red Butte Gardens August 18. Wilco demonstrated why they are a hard band to ...

Is this the day the music dies? - Computerworld

dBTechno

Is this the day the music dies?
Computerworld, MA -Aug 19, 2008
I've never been a fan of current popular music -- my tastes run to the eclectic (klezmer), the badly out-of-date (1920s and 1930s pop) and downright boring ...
Music Biz *Still* Trying to Kill Web RadioWashington Post
Quick! Listen to Pandora while you still canMLive.com
Pandora Closing Music Box Soon?G4 TV
Audio Graphics - TG Daily
all 91 news articles

Atlanta Music Scene - Atlanta Journal Constitution

Atlanta Music Scene
Atlanta Journal Constitution,  USA -4 hours ago
“And it’sa compliment that that man found inspiration in the music I do for the streets over here, over there in Beijing”. (It would also be quite the ...

Glasgow gets city of music honour - BBC News

BBC News

Glasgow gets city of music honour
BBC News, UK -2 hours ago
Glasgow is aiming to build on its rich musical heritage after it was named a United Nations City of Music. The honour, bestowed by the UN cultural body, ...
Unesco music honour for GlasgowThe Press Association
Glasgow Rocks as it Wins UNESCO City of Music StatusTravel Agent
Glasgow wins City of Music statusOpodo
stv.tv - BBC News
all 21 news articles

Party time! Convention delegates face the music - The Associated Press

Party time! Convention delegates face the music
The Associated Press -2 hours ago
... organized by Planned Parenthood and the "Tent State Music Festival to End the War" hosted by Rage Against the Machine and veterans opposed to the war. ...

Control Room Presents Live Performances From Virgin Mobile ... - FOXBusiness

Control Room Presents Live Performances From Virgin Mobile ...
FOXBusiness -59 minutes ago
Taking Back Sunday http://music.msn.com/virgin-festival3 "Virgin Mobile USA provided us with an amazing opportunity to offer a wide variety of phenomenal ...

Triad anchors sign on to narrate Carolina Summer Music Festival ... - Bizjournals.com

Triad anchors sign on to narrate Carolina Summer Music Festival ...
Bizjournals.com, NC -1 hour ago
Two Triad TV news personalities have signed on to narrate the Carolina Scrapbook family concerts, part of the inaugural Carolina Summer Music Festival. ...

Contemporary Christian Music Featured Sunday, Aug. 31 at Powers ... - MarketWatch

Contemporary Christian Music Featured Sunday, Aug. 31 at Powers ...
MarketWatch -1 hour ago
Contemporary Christian radio station J93.3, WVFJ-FM, Atlanta, is sponsoring the afternoon of music. The festival, which is held every year on the rolling ...