Jazz: What In The Heck Is It?


All of us know what jazz is when we hear it, but trying to define it is a different matter. With so many variant styles, coming up with an accurate definition of jazz is difficult if not impossible.

But I suppose that an article on jazz really ought to attempt to define the term "jazz." My Thorndike-Barnhart Dictionary defines jazz like this:

*jazz (jaz), noun. 1. American music with the accents falling at unusual places; syncopated music. 2. Slang, liveliness ? adj. of or like jazz: a jazz band.

Besides not telling us very much, it is also obviously false. I think immediately of ballads played by jazz musicians, such as Thelonious Monk's 'Round Midnight and Bill Evan's Peace Piece, and countless other examples. They are based on neither syncopation nor liveliness; they are slow, extremely thoughtful, and the antithesis of "jazzy." Yet they are considered by both jazz musicians and jazz critics alike to be well within the mainstream of jazz.

Let's try A New Dictionary of Music and see if we can get closer to the essence of jazz:

*jazz, a term used at least from 1914 for a type of American popular music originating among blacks of New Orleans and taken over also by whites; also used generally for various types of dance music indebted to this (though purists reserve the term for such music as retains the original flavor and the original basis of improvisation.) The jazz idiom, characterized by certain syncopations over strongly reiterated rhythms, has influenced e.g. Lambert, Stravinsky, and Milhaud, as well as many American composers.

That's better than the Thorndike-Barnhart definition, but it still leans heavily toward defining jazz in terms of rhythm alone: "characterized by certain syncopations over strongly reiterated rhythms." I think again of ballads, but also of much contemporary jazz which is not characterized by "certain syncopations,: such as the work of pianists Keith Jarrett and Chick Corea.

What then is jazz? If the general dictionaries and musical dictionaries can't satisfactorily answer the question, what hope is there for us?

Ask a hundred jazz musicians what jazz is, and you'll get a hundred different answers (I know ? I've asked at least a dozen and gotten as many different responses.)

I would like to suggest that the answer may lie, not in music, but in semantics.

I think it is entirely possible that we are lumping together widely disparate types of music, and labeling them all with the term "jazz," then wondering why we can't come up with a lexical definition of the term. Maybe we should abandon the word "jazz," and use terms such as "improvised fast syncopated music," or "improvised slow non-syncopated music." Maybe we should, but we won't. So we are stuck with the non-definable term "jazz."

So let's not define jazz.

We all know what it is, more or less. We would disagree mainly in the "grey" areas, such as ballads, some contemporary works, and so forth. But let's agree not to disagree, and just enjoy it.

The following articles in this series will deal with the various styles we find in jazz, from ragtime to fusion.

So stay tuned.

Duane Shinn is the author of over 500 music books and music educational materials such as DVD's, CD's, musical games for kids, chord charts, musical software, and piano lesson instructional courses for adults. His course on blues and jazz improvisation titled "How To Make Up Music As You Go Along: Improvising On The Piano!" is being used by musicians and pianists around the world. He holds advanced degrees from Southern Oregon University and was the founder of Piano University in Southern Oregon. He is the author of the popular free 101-week online e-mail newsletter titled Amazing Secrets Of Exciting Piano Chords & Sizzling Chord Progressions! with over 57,400 current subscribers.







Related News



Triad anchors sign on to narrate Carolina Summer Music Festival ... - Bizjournals.com

Triad anchors sign on to narrate Carolina Summer Music Festival ...
Bizjournals.com, NC -1 hour ago
Two Triad TV news personalities have signed on to narrate the Carolina Scrapbook family concerts, part of the inaugural Carolina Summer Music Festival. ...

Music review: Wilco impressive in one of best concerts of the summer - Salt Lake Tribune

Music review: Wilco impressive in one of best concerts of the summer
Salt Lake Tribune, United States -11 hours ago
By David Burger Jeff Tweedy sings while John Stirratt plays bass as Wilco plays Red Butte Gardens August 18. Wilco demonstrated why they are a hard band to ...

Atlanta Music Scene - Atlanta Journal Constitution

Atlanta Music Scene
Atlanta Journal Constitution,  USA -4 hours ago
“And it’sa compliment that that man found inspiration in the music I do for the streets over here, over there in Beijing”. (It would also be quite the ...

Is this the day the music dies? - Computerworld

The Tech Herald

Is this the day the music dies?
Computerworld, MA -Aug 19, 2008
I've never been a fan of current popular music -- my tastes run to the eclectic (klezmer), the badly out-of-date (1920s and 1930s pop) and downright boring ...
Music Biz *Still* Trying to Kill Web RadioWashington Post
Quick! Listen to Pandora while you still canMLive.com
Pandora Closing Music Box Soon?G4 TV
Audio Graphics - TG Daily
all 91 news articles

Party time! Convention delegates face the music - The Associated Press

Party time! Convention delegates face the music
The Associated Press -3 hours ago
... organized by Planned Parenthood and the "Tent State Music Festival to End the War" hosted by Rage Against the Machine and veterans opposed to the war. ...

Glasgow gets city of music honour - BBC News

BBC News

Glasgow gets city of music honour
BBC News, UK -2 hours ago
Glasgow is aiming to build on its rich musical heritage after it was named a United Nations City of Music. The honour, bestowed by the UN cultural body, ...
Unesco music honour for GlasgowThe Press Association
Glasgow Rocks as it Wins UNESCO City of Music StatusTravel Agent
Glasgow wins City of Music statusOpodo
stv.tv - BBC News
all 21 news articles

Contemporary Christian Music Featured Sunday, Aug. 31 at Powers ... - MarketWatch

Contemporary Christian Music Featured Sunday, Aug. 31 at Powers ...
MarketWatch -1 hour ago
Contemporary Christian radio station J93.3, WVFJ-FM, Atlanta, is sponsoring the afternoon of music. The festival, which is held every year on the rolling ...

Atlantic's Jerry Wexler Showed - Wall Street Journal

BBC News

Atlantic's Jerry Wexler Showed
Wall Street Journal -Aug 18, 2008
The 14 albums Wexler and Franklin made together resulted in music for the ages. As a producer, Wexler made records to capture moments born of preparation ...
Legendary Hitmaker Jerry WexlerNPR
Legendary Music Executive Jerry Wexler Passed Away At His Home In ...AHN
JERRY WEXLER 1917-2008 jerry wexler A music great rememberedUncut.co.uk
Chatter Shmatter - Washington Post
all 852 news articles

Support Grows For Blanket Music Licensing - Slashdot

Support Grows For Blanket Music Licensing
Slashdot -6 hours ago
Anti-Globalism sends in Ars coverage of a speech by Jim Griffin, who is a consultant for Warner, one of the big four music labels. ...
Support Grows For Blanket Music LicensingSlashdot
all 4 news articles


Control Room Presents Live Performances From Virgin Mobile ... - FOXBusiness

Control Room Presents Live Performances From Virgin Mobile ...
FOXBusiness -1 hour ago
Taking Back Sunday http://music.msn.com/virgin-festival3 "Virgin Mobile USA provided us with an amazing opportunity to offer a wide variety of phenomenal ...