Chords or Melody First... Which is Best?


There are basically two ways you can compose a piece of music. The first and most traditional way is to write out the melody and then harmonize it. Some call this working from the top (as opposed to the chords on the bottom.) The second approach is where you create some kind of rhythmic harmonic pattern and improvise (or compose) the melody on top. Now, which one is best for New Age music?

The answer is neither approach. Each has its own merits and own special benefits. For example, if you start with a pattern in your left hand and improvise a melody with your right, you are doing what most new age composers/improvisers do. This is what George Winston does most of the time. He has chords he sets to a certain rhythm and does his thing with that amazing right hand of his.

This is the style that I have been playing, but I've recently lost interest in it. Not because it isn't good but because I don't feel like playing that way anymore. Currently I'm leaning towards a softer sound that comes from leading with the melody first. What I do is get the first 2-bars down and then improvise the rest till I fill up 8 measures. This way I can vary the chords and patterns without it sounding very repetitive (minimalism). It's actually another style. You can call it melodic while the other one (Harmony approach) is more textural. IT ALL DEPENDS ON YOUR MOOD!

Don't let one style freeze you into something where you can't maneuver artistically! Remember that your feeling must come first. Everything else is secondary. Let your feeling lead you and your creation will be truly inspired, however, if you try to mold what you have to say into a specific style, the result may be less than satisfactory.

Edward Weiss is a pianist/composer and webmaster of Quiescence Music's online piano lessons. He has been helping students learn how to play piano in the New Age style for over 14 years and works with students in private, in groups, and now over the internet. Stop by now at http://www.quiescencemusic.com/piano_lessons.html for a FREE piano lesson!







Related News



Triad anchors sign on to narrate Carolina Summer Music Festival ... - Bizjournals.com

Triad anchors sign on to narrate Carolina Summer Music Festival ...
Bizjournals.com, NC -1 hour ago
Two Triad TV news personalities have signed on to narrate the Carolina Scrapbook family concerts, part of the inaugural Carolina Summer Music Festival. ...

Atlantic's Jerry Wexler Showed - Wall Street Journal

BBC News

Atlantic's Jerry Wexler Showed
Wall Street Journal -Aug 18, 2008
The 14 albums Wexler and Franklin made together resulted in music for the ages. As a producer, Wexler made records to capture moments born of preparation ...
Legendary Hitmaker Jerry WexlerNPR
Legendary Music Executive Jerry Wexler Passed Away At His Home In ...AHN
JERRY WEXLER 1917-2008 jerry wexler A music great rememberedUncut.co.uk
Chatter Shmatter - Washington Post
all 852 news articles

Support Grows For Blanket Music Licensing - Slashdot

Support Grows For Blanket Music Licensing
Slashdot -6 hours ago
Anti-Globalism sends in Ars coverage of a speech by Jim Griffin, who is a consultant for Warner, one of the big four music labels. ...
Support Grows For Blanket Music LicensingSlashdot
all 4 news articles

Glasgow gets city of music honour - BBC News

BBC News

Glasgow gets city of music honour
BBC News, UK -2 hours ago
Glasgow is aiming to build on its rich musical heritage after it was named a United Nations City of Music. The honour, bestowed by the UN cultural body, ...
Unesco music honour for GlasgowThe Press Association
Glasgow Rocks as it Wins UNESCO City of Music StatusTravel Agent
Glasgow wins City of Music statusOpodo
stv.tv - BBC News
all 21 news articles

Party time! Convention delegates face the music - The Associated Press

Party time! Convention delegates face the music
The Associated Press -3 hours ago
... organized by Planned Parenthood and the "Tent State Music Festival to End the War" hosted by Rage Against the Machine and veterans opposed to the war. ...

Is this the day the music dies? - Computerworld

The Tech Herald

Is this the day the music dies?
Computerworld, MA -Aug 19, 2008
I've never been a fan of current popular music -- my tastes run to the eclectic (klezmer), the badly out-of-date (1920s and 1930s pop) and downright boring ...
Music Biz *Still* Trying to Kill Web RadioWashington Post
Quick! Listen to Pandora while you still canMLive.com
Pandora Closing Music Box Soon?G4 TV
Audio Graphics - TG Daily
all 91 news articles

Control Room Presents Live Performances From Virgin Mobile ... - FOXBusiness

Control Room Presents Live Performances From Virgin Mobile ...
FOXBusiness -1 hour ago
Taking Back Sunday http://music.msn.com/virgin-festival3 "Virgin Mobile USA provided us with an amazing opportunity to offer a wide variety of phenomenal ...


Contemporary Christian Music Featured Sunday, Aug. 31 at Powers ... - MarketWatch

Contemporary Christian Music Featured Sunday, Aug. 31 at Powers ...
MarketWatch -1 hour ago
Contemporary Christian radio station J93.3, WVFJ-FM, Atlanta, is sponsoring the afternoon of music. The festival, which is held every year on the rolling ...

Atlanta Music Scene - Atlanta Journal Constitution

Atlanta Music Scene
Atlanta Journal Constitution,  USA -4 hours ago
“And it’sa compliment that that man found inspiration in the music I do for the streets over here, over there in Beijing”. (It would also be quite the ...

Music review: Wilco impressive in one of best concerts of the summer - Salt Lake Tribune

Music review: Wilco impressive in one of best concerts of the summer
Salt Lake Tribune, United States -11 hours ago
By David Burger Jeff Tweedy sings while John Stirratt plays bass as Wilco plays Red Butte Gardens August 18. Wilco demonstrated why they are a hard band to ...