Music & Citizenship: Can Playing a Musical Instrument Help Your Child Become a Better Citizen?


Disregard the popular image of rappers with their ghetto blasters, terrorizing neighborhoods with eardrum-splitting cacophony. Consider instead our delightful school bands and orchestras? and ponder on whether those students might be becoming our best future citizens.

Unlikely as it may seem, recent scientific research suggests this hypothesis might actually be true. It appears studying music can, in fact, impact the development of the human personality, especially in the area of socialization. In particular, music education encourages self-discipline and diligence, traits which carry over into other areas.

According to statistics compiled by the National Data Resource Center, students who can be classified as 'disruptive' (based on factors such as frequent skipping of classes, times in trouble, in-school suspensions, disciplinary reasons given, arrests, and drop-outs) total 12.14 percent of the total school population. In contrast, only 8.08 percent of students involved in music classes meet the same criteria as 'disruptive'.

Neurobiologist Norman Weinberger reports on another research study by Martin Gardiner of Brown University. According to Weinberger, writing in the Winter 2000 Issue of MuSICA Research Notes, Gardiner's study checked the relationship between arrest records of teenagers and their degree of involvement in music. He analyzed a large-scale data base that included information gathered over a period of many years for more than a thousand residents of Rhode Island.

Gardiner tracked people from birth through the age of thirty, and found that the greater the involvement in music, the lower the arrest record. Teens who had music education were less likely to get into trouble than students who didn't. However, those who were also involved in playing a musical instrument had even fewer brushes with the law. Those who had the most experience, including good sight-reading ability, had a negligible arrest record.

Gardiner's study, which took place in 2000, is backed by others. The National Association for Music Education publishes a fact sheet on its website which quotes the Texas Commission on Drug and Alcohol Abuse Report. According to the January 1998 report, secondary students who participated in band or orchestra reported the lowest lifetime - and current - use of all substances (alcohol, tobacco and illicit drugs).

And a 1990 study at the National Arts Education Research Center, concluded that students who participated in arts programs in selected elementary and middle schools in New York City showed significant increases in self-esteem and thinking skills.

The results of studies such as these are promising for the future of our society, especially in the light of a 2003 Gallup Poll Survey showing record numbers of Americans now play musical instruments.

This survey - conducted by the Gallup Organization (commissioned by NAMM, the National Association of Music Merchants) - found that Americans are playing musical instruments at the highest levels since 1978.

Just over half, (54 percent), of households surveyed had a member who plays a musical instrument. And in 48 percent of households where at least one person played an instrument, there were two or more additional members who also played.

Ninety-seven percent of respondents agreed that playing a musical instrument provides a sense of accomplishment and encourages expression, and 85 percent believe it makes someone smarter. An equal number regretted not learning to play an instrument and 67 percent said they would still like to learn.

Interestingly, the survey also showed that an increasing number of young people are becoming involved in music, with the percentage of people ages of 5 to 17 who play an instrument at 31 percent, up from 25 percent in 1985.

Of the total respondents a further 27 percent were between the ages of 18 to 24.

Most of those questioned began their music education before their teens with 64 percent saying they started music study between the ages of 5 to 11 and 18 percent between the ages of 12 to 14.

In his highly acclaimed book, A Users Guide to the Brain, Ratey John J, MD notes: "The musician is constantly adjusting decisions on tempo, style, rhythm, phrasing and feeling - training the brain to become incredibly good at organizing and conducting numerous activities at once. Dedicated practice of this orchestration can have a great payoff for lifelong attention skills, intelligence and an ability for self-knowledge and expression."

Good citizens require many of these same skills in order to live harmoniously with other human beings. So as you move to a new town or take up a new job, it could just be worth enquiring if your neighbors and colleagues are musicians.

Duane Shinn is the author of over 500 music books and music educational materials such as DVD's, CD's, musical games for kids, chord charts, musical software, and piano lesson instructional courses for adults. His book-CD-DVD course titled "How To Play Chord Piano" (http://www.chordpiano.com) has sold over 100,000 copies around the world. He holds an advanced degree from Southern Oregon University and was the founder of Piano University in Southern Oregon. Previous to that he worked as an assistant music therapist at DeWitt State Hospital in Auburn, California. He can be reached at http://www.pianolessonsbyvideo.com. He is the author of the popular free 101-week e-mail newsletter titled "Amazing Secrets Of Exciting Piano Chords & Sizzling Chord Progressions" with over 55,000 current subscribers. Those interested may obtain a free subscription by going to http://www.playpiano.com/







Related News



Support Grows For Blanket Music Licensing - Slashdot

Support Grows For Blanket Music Licensing
Slashdot -23 hours ago
Anti-Globalism sends in Ars coverage of a speech by Jim Griffin, who consultant for Warner, one of the big four music labels. Griffin is encouraging dialog ...
Support Grows For Blanket Music LicensingSlashdot
all 4 news articles


Paltalk and Island Def Jam Music Group/Mercury Records Announce ... - Earthtimes (press release)

Paltalk and Island Def Jam Music Group/Mercury Records Announce ...
Earthtimes (press release), UK -5 hours ago
One Block Radius, which is comprised of music veterans Marty James , DJ MDA, and MC Z-Man, will be performing live during the episode, and participating in ...

Is this the day the music dies? - Computerworld

The Tech Herald

Is this the day the music dies?
Computerworld, MA -Aug 19, 2008
I've never been a fan of current popular music -- my tastes run to the eclectic (klezmer), the badly out-of-date (1920s and 1930s pop) and downright boring ...
Music Biz *Still* Trying to Kill Web RadioWashington Post
Quick! Listen to Pandora while you still canMLive.com
Pandora Closing Music Box Soon?G4 TV
TG Daily - p2pnet.net
all 91 news articles

The Music Column: WE-play - StarNewsOnline.com

The Music Column: WE-play
StarNewsOnline.com, NC -58 minutes ago
Nope, five days of wall-to-wall bands over Memorial Day weekend on all four levels of downtown music venue The Soapbox (255 N. Front St.) just didn't ...

Music series begins - Columbia County News Times

Metro Spirit

Music series begins
Columbia County News Times, GA -4 hours ago
By Jenna Martin The sounds of music will drift from the Columbia County Amphitheater each Thursday for the next four weeks. Savage Lucy will kick off the ...
Mass appealMetro Spirit
all 2 news articles

Cuts play like sour note in arts, music community - Philadelphia Daily News

Cuts play like sour note in arts, music community
Philadelphia Daily News, PA -4 hours ago
Even worse, the VH1 Save the Music Foundation, a donor of more than $1.18 million in musical instruments to city schools since 1999, is warning the district ...
Upheaval over arts, music funding in Phila. schoolsPhiladelphia Inquirer
all 2 news articles

Music review: Wilco impressive in one of best concerts of the summer - Salt Lake Tribune

Music review: Wilco impressive in one of best concerts of the summer
Salt Lake Tribune, United States -11 hours ago
By David Burger Jeff Tweedy sings while John Stirratt plays bass as Wilco plays Red Butte Gardens August 18. Wilco demonstrated why they are a hard band to ...

Atlantic's Jerry Wexler Showed - Wall Street Journal

BBC News

Atlantic's Jerry Wexler Showed
Wall Street Journal -Aug 18, 2008
The 14 albums Wexler and Franklin made together resulted in music for the ages. As a producer, Wexler made records to capture moments born of preparation ...
Legendary Music Executive Jerry Wexler Passed Away At His Home In ...AHN
JERRY WEXLER 1917-2008 jerry wexler A music great rememberedUncut.co.uk
Music Producer Jerry Wexler Dead At 91Chatter Shmatter
Washington Post - MarketWatch
all 852 news articles

Unesco music honour for Glasgow - The Press Association

BBC News

Unesco music honour for Glasgow
The Press Association -3 hours ago
Scotland's biggest city has been named a Unesco City of Music in recognition of its musical pedigree. Glasgow is the third city in the world to receive the ...
Glasgow wins City of Music statusOpodo
Charting Glasgow's musical pastBBC News
Glasgow hits all right notes to become UNESCO 'world centre of music'Scotsman
The Herald - Thaindian.com
all 21 news articles

Atlanta Music Scene - Atlanta Journal Constitution

Atlanta Music Scene
Atlanta Journal Constitution,  USA -4 hours ago
“And it’sa compliment that that man found inspiration in the music I do for the streets over here, over there in Beijing”. (It would also be quite the ...