Why Do Music Lovers Still Prefer to Buy Records?


In the late 1940's, the 45-RPM record replaced the 78-RPM record. The 45 was smaller, less breakable and could be made and sold more cheaply. Despite these advantages, it took ten years before the 78 became obsolete, and in the meantime, record companies sold their product in both formats. In 1982, the major record companies introduced the compact disc, which offered a smaller size, "perfect" sound, and less likelihood of damage in day to day use. As the compact disc offered a much larger profit margin than did the long-play record album (LP) the record companies were eager to rid store shelves of records once and for all. Given that the 78 lasted ten years after the introduction of the 45, it seemed likely that the LP would be gone from the market by 1990. The expected disappearance of the LP never happened. Despite the efforts of the music industry, music fans and collectors not only continue to buy records today, but sales of records and record-playing equipment are on the rise.

Each year in January, the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) is held in Las Vegas. At this event, audio and video manufacturers show off the latest and greatest in their product lines. An unusual sight this year was not the large number of cutting-edge compact disc players, but the largest number of record turntables that had been seen at the event in years! Sales of both new and used records are hot, and equipment manufacturers are eager to reintroduce the turntables they quit making years ago. Why are record sales increasing when compact discs are supposed to provide perfect sound in an unbreakable format? There are several reasons:

  • Price. Price is always a factor when consumers buy anything and the prices of new and used record albums are less than the prices of new and used compact discs, respectively. Used CDs may sell for $5-8; used record albums sell for $3-5
  • Physical size. A lot of people prefer the larger size of record albums. They don't store as easily as compact discs, but the covers and lyrics are easier to read, and the product feels more substantial. Buyers feel like they're getting "more" for their money, even if it's just extra weight.
  • Sound. The digital sound of compact discs has a certain cleanness and purity to it, but many listeners find the sound of compact discs to be "artificial" or "metallic", lacking the "warmth" of the sound of a record. Arguments have been going on for years, and fans of compact discs claim that there really is no difference in sound, but millions of record fans would probably disagree.
  • Nostalgia. A lot of Baby Boomers grew up listening to records, and records have a fond familiarity to them that listeners like.
  • New record albums continue to be released every day. Aided by artists who are still recording who demand that their albums be released as both records and compact discs, such as Diana Krall, Pink Floyd, and Metallica, record album sales continue to thrive. Despite industry efforts to kill the format back in the 1980's, It appears that the record album will continue to live on, well into the twenty-first century, and music fans couldn't be happier about it.

    ©Copyright 2005 by Retro Marketing.

    Charles Essmeier is the owner of Retro Marketing, a firm that operates several retail Websites, including AluminumChristmasTrees.net, a site devoted to vintage aluminum Christmas trees and accessories, and RarePinkFloyd.com, a site devoted to rare records, compact discs and by the band Pink Floyd.







    Related News



    Wal-Mart Reverses Decision To Shutdown Digital Music DRM Servers - InformationWeek

    PC World

    Wal-Mart Reverses Decision To Shutdown Digital Music DRM Servers
    InformationWeek, NY -Oct 10, 2008
    Wal-Mart's original plans would have made its DRM-protected tracks difficult to play on a PC, unless the music was first burned to a CD. ...
    Wal-Mart's DRM Nightmare Just Won't EndWired News
    Wal-Mart reversal teaches us you guys have mightCNET News
    Wal-Mart Backs Down on DRM DecisionPC World
    CRN - CrunchGear
    all 31 news articles

    Gospel music festival coming to Utah in 2009 - Salt Lake Tribune

    Gospel music festival coming to Utah in 2009
    Salt Lake Tribune, United States -18 hours ago
    AP LOGAN - The state tourism board has agreed to spend more than $10000 to promote a gospel music festival. The Utah Board of Tourism Development will spend ...

    Pizarro: San Jose's Music in the Other Park series won't be coming ... - San Jose Mercury News

    Pizarro: San Jose's Music in the Other Park series won't be coming ...
    San Jose Mercury News,  USA -17 hours ago
    By Sal Pizarro The San Jose Downtown Association is rethinking its summer music series in St. James Park, and that may turn out to be a very good thing. ...


    Guest commentary: Music is fundamental part of well-rounded education - Naples Daily News

    Guest commentary: Music is fundamental part of well-rounded education
    Naples Daily News, FL -1 hour ago
    By ROBERT HEARSON, Naples As a retired music educator with a 42-year career of dedicated service to both public school and collegiate music students, ...
    School Page: Collier education briefs for October 12, 2008Naples Daily News
    all 4 news articles

    Music Center parking loss creates traffic bottleneck for patrons - Los Angeles Times

    Music Center parking loss creates traffic bottleneck for patrons
    Los Angeles Times, CA -4 hours ago
    A no-show actor, singer or soloist at a Music Center performance could throw things into disarray. Ditto for a missing parking lot. ...

    Tim Robbins discusses music venture - The Press Association

    Tim Robbins discusses music venture
    The Press Association -5 hours ago
    He's an award-winning actor, writer and director, and Tim Robbins has revealed he's expanding his talent into music. "I've just finished recording an album ...
    Today, Tonight, TomorrowFayObserver.com
    City of EmberVariety
    all 441 news articles

    Music video highlights: NLCS Game 2 - MLB.com

    Bleacher Report

    Music video highlights: NLCS Game 2
    MLB.com -2 hours ago
    MLB.com/Entertainment is all over Rocktober, with daily videos featuring the best baseball highlights of October set to music by stars including Santana, ...
    Impostors ruining Dodgers' feel-good storyLos Angeles Times
    all 127 news articles

    MTV tunes out music videos - Newsday

    MTV tunes out music videos
    Newsday, NY -Oct 10, 2008
    The labels seem to be trying a similar strategy with their music video premieres. With MTV so uninterested in videos that it is even phasing out "TRL," the ...
    Video: Sneak Peak: Britney Opens Up in New DocumentaryAssociatedPress
    Britney Spears looks at her past with regretOneindia
    Britney Spears 'Womanizer' Video (See It Here!)TheImproper.com
    Hartford Courant - News10.net
    all 712 news articles

    YouTube introduces music downloads - NME.com

    Canada.com

    YouTube introduces music downloads
    NME.com, UK -Oct 9, 2008
    Video sharing website YouTube bosses have introduced a new feature that allows users to download music via the site. Through the new program users are able ...
    YouTube to help sell musicCollege News
    YouTube adds "click-to-buy" for music, video gamesComputerworld
    YouTube flips switch on new sales channelThe Associated Press
    Reuters - Seattle Post Intelligencer
    all 471 news articles

    Music exec Flom lines up Universal post - Reuters

    Music exec Flom lines up Universal post
    Reuters -Oct 10, 2008
    UMG chairman/CEO Doug Morris was a mentor to Flom when the latter started Lava Records as an imprint of Atlantic and Morris was chairman of Warner Music...
    paidContent.org - UMG CEO: Piracy Will Be Solved By Technology ...Washington Post
    all 6 news articles